Online calculators multiply your medical bills by a number and call it a settlement. Real claims are valued on what the injury has cost you and will cost you, reduced by fault and limited by the insurance available.
Updated November 2026
This page is attorney advertising. It offers general information about Missouri law and is not legal or medical advice for your situation. Reading this page or contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship, which is formed only by a written agreement signed by both you and the firm. Any case results described are specific to the facts of those cases; past results do not guarantee, warrant, or predict a similar outcome in any other matter. Finney Injury Law is licensed to practice law in the State of Missouri. The full disclaimer appears at the bottom of this page.
No formula produces the value of an injury claim. Two people with the same broken bone can have very different claims, because one lost months of work and the other did not, or one had a clear-cut crash and the other shared blame.
What you can do is understand the pieces an insurer and a jury look at, so you recognize a low offer when you see one and know what to protect before you agree to anything.
Bills so far are only part of it. A serious injury may need surgery, therapy, or care for years. A claim that ignores future treatment prices the injury as if it ended on the day you stopped seeing the doctor.
Missed paychecks count. So can a lasting limit on the work you can do, such as a job you can no longer perform or hours you can no longer keep. This is often the largest piece in a serious injury.
Missouri law allows recovery for physical pain and for what the injury takes from daily life. This is the part insurers undervalue most, and the part that depends most on how well your story is documented.
Under Missouri's pure comparative fault system, your share of fault, if any, reduces the total. The at-fault driver's coverage can cap what is collectable, and health insurer or medical provider reimbursement claims come out of a settlement, so the number that matters is what you keep.
An insurance company told our client that a wrist fracture from a car crash had healed and offered an amount to match. We did not agree and took the case to trial.
A unanimous jury decided it in 15 minutes, at more than ten times the last offer: $750,000.
Past results do not guarantee a future outcome, and every case depends on its own facts. These are public-record results in car accident cases.
The insurance company said the wrist fracture had healed. A unanimous jury disagreed in 15 minutes, at more than 10 times the last offer. Read full story →
The defense blamed a self-employed mechanic's injuries on pre-existing arthritis and repetitive work. A Jefferson County jury disagreed. Read full story →
A red light runner. Multiple disc replacements, a lower back fusion, and blood clots. A St. Louis County jury returned $10,000,000. Read full story →
Gaps in treatment and skipped appointments are used to argue the injury was minor. Records made close to the crash are the strongest proof of what it did to you.
Medical bills, prescriptions, mileage to appointments, and proof of missed work all become part of the number. Keep a short daily note of pain and what you cannot do.
A first offer often arrives before the doctors know whether you need surgery or long-term care. A settlement is final, so it should come after your treatment is understood.
Statements to the other driver's insurer are used to reduce a claim. Refer the adjuster to your lawyer.
A review is free here, and it is the fastest way to learn whether an offer is close to the value of your claim or far from it.
There is no reliable average, because claims range from minor soft-tissue injuries to catastrophic ones. What a claim is worth depends on your medical treatment, lost income, the effect on your life, who was at fault, and the insurance available.
Not one that works. Some insurers and websites multiply medical bills by a number, but that ignores future care, lost earning ability, and how strongly the evidence supports fault. Use any calculator as a rough idea, not an estimate.
Yes. Missouri uses pure comparative fault, so your recovery is reduced by your percentage of fault rather than barred. If you are found 20 percent at fault, the amount is reduced by that share.
The at-fault driver's policy limits can cap what you collect from that policy. You may have other coverage, such as underinsured motorist coverage on your own policy, so check your coverage before accepting a limit offer.
Usually not before you understand the full injury. First offers are often made early, before the extent of your treatment is known, and a settlement is final. Have a lawyer review it first.
Not always. Health insurers, medical providers, and attorney fees can come out of a settlement, so the number you keep may differ from the number offered. A lawyer can explain what is owed and what can be negotiated.
It depends on how long treatment lasts and whether the insurer disputes fault or the injury. Settling before you know your recovery risks leaving money behind, so a serious claim often takes longer than a minor one.
No cost, no obligation, and nothing is shared outside our firm. We read every message and respond quickly.
Free case review. An attorney personally reviews every case. English- and Spanish-speaking staff available.