If you were hurt in Arnold, Festus, Imperial, High Ridge, or on the I-55 corridor, you will find a long list of firms that all say the same things. This guide skips the ranking and gives you the questions that separate them, and how to check the answers yourself.
Updated September 2026
This page is attorney advertising. It offers general information about Missouri law and is not legal or medical advice for your situation. Reading this page or contacting the firm does not create an attorney-client relationship, which is formed only by a written agreement signed by both you and the firm. Any case results described are specific to the facts of those cases; past results do not guarantee, warrant, or predict a similar outcome in any other matter. Finney Injury Law is licensed to practice law in the State of Missouri. The full disclaimer appears at the bottom of this page.
This article does not rank any firm, ours included. A list of the best injury lawyers is an opinion, and many published lists are paid placement. What you can actually use is a short set of things that differ from one firm to the next, and a way to confirm each one without taking anyone's word for it.
Jefferson County adds a few questions of its own. It sits between a major metro court system and a smaller county seat, its serious crashes cluster on I-55 and on two-lane county roads, and people there often assume they must hire a lawyer from the county. Neither assumption has to be true. Here is how to think it through.
Some of these you can verify from public records before you call. The rest you have to ask, and how plainly a firm answers is itself information.
Almost every firm says it will go to trial. Ask how many cases it has tried to verdict in the last three years, and in which counties. Missouri court records are public and searchable through Case.net, so the answer can be checked. Insurers price a claim partly on whether the firm across the table is known to try cases or known to settle them, and that reputation is built in courtrooms, not advertisements.
Judges, jury pools, and local practice differ from county to county, and a firm that knows the courthouse has a real advantage. Where a case can be filed is set by Missouri's venue rules, and it is not always the county where you live. Ask the firm which court your case would most likely be filed in, and why. A good answer is specific. A vague one tells you the question had not been thought through.
At some firms the lawyer in the advertisement is not the person handling your case, and the file is run largely by case managers with periodic attorney review. Ask which attorney is responsible for yours, whether you will meet them before you sign, and who you call with a question. For a serious injury these are the judgment calls that matter: which experts to retain, when to refuse an offer, and whether to file suit.
Crashes on I-55 and the county's two-lane routes frequently involve commercial trucks, and a truck case depends on records the carrier controls and routinely overwrites. Ask whether the firm sends preservation letters immediately and whether it has handled commercial vehicle cases. A firm that has never done so will be learning on your case while the evidence disappears.
The contingency fee is a percentage of the recovery. Case costs are the separate expenses of building the case: experts, depositions, medical records, filing fees. In a serious case those can reach five or six figures. Ask what the percentage is, whether it increases if the case is filed or tried, and who pays the costs if there is no recovery. The answer belongs in the written agreement.
A red light runner left our client with multiple disc replacements, a lower back fusion, and blood clots. A St. Louis County jury returned $10,000,000.
We include it because it answers the first question on this list. It is a result reached in a courtroom, in a metro-area county, and it can be checked against the public record rather than taken on faith.
Past results do not guarantee a future outcome, and every case depends on its own facts. These are public-record results shown for what they say about trial preparation. Ask any firm, including ours, about experience in Jefferson County specifically.
A red light runner. Multiple disc replacements, a lower back fusion, and blood clots. A St. Louis County jury returned $10,000,000. Read full story →
Defense offered $0 and blamed the mother for her son's death. After five days of trial, a St. Charles County jury delivered $20,025,000. Read full story →
A young, active client was left with permanent injuries after a serious car accident. Resolved before trial for $2 million. Read full story →
A head injury caused by an underinsured driver. We recovered $250,000 through our client's own insurance coverage. Read full story →
Then ask in which counties. Missouri Case.net lets you verify the answer. A firm that cannot name recent trials is a firm that settles, which is worth knowing before you sign.
The answer depends on Missouri's venue rules and the facts of your crash. A specific answer shows the firm has thought about your case rather than recited a pitch.
Follow with: will I meet that attorney before I sign, and who do I call with a question? If everything routes through a case manager, you have learned how the firm is structured.
In a serious crash the answer should include preserving evidence, identifying every insurance policy that might apply, and routing insurer contact through the firm. If the first week sounds like waiting, keep looking.
Get all three in the written agreement. Case costs are separate from the fee and can be substantial in a serious case.
No. Where your lawyer's office is does not determine where your case is heard. What matters is whether the firm handles cases in the court where yours would be filed and is prepared to try it. Many Missouri firms handle cases across several counties, so ask about the specific court rather than the address on the letterhead.
Ask how many cases it has tried to verdict in the last three years and in which counties, then verify it. Missouri court records are public and searchable through Case.net. Most injury cases settle regardless of the firm, so the question is not whether a firm settles, but whether it is genuinely prepared to try a case when the offer does not reflect what it is worth.
Treat them carefully. Many directory rankings are paid placement, sponsored content, or built from submitted information rather than independent review, and the criteria are often undisclosed. The safer approach is to verify the things that matter directly: the trial record, who handles the file, and the fee terms.
The contingency fee is the percentage of the recovery the firm is paid, and it is only paid if there is a recovery. Case costs are the out-of-pocket expenses of building the case: experts, depositions, records, and court fees. Ask what the percentage is, whether it increases at trial, and who is responsible for costs if the case is lost.
Sooner than most people do. Physical evidence gets repaired or discarded, surveillance video is overwritten on cycles measured in days or weeks, and insurers begin building their file immediately. Missouri's general limitation period for personal injury is five years, but the practical deadline that decides cases arrives long before that.
Not necessarily, but get a second opinion before treating it as final. Firms decline cases for reasons unrelated to the merits, including caseload, cost exposure, and whether the case fits how that firm works. A decline from one firm is one firm's assessment.
No cost, no obligation, and nothing is shared outside our firm. We read every message and respond quickly.
The decisions you make in the days after an injury affect your ability to recover fair compensation. Free case review. An attorney personally reviews every case. English- and Spanish-speaking staff available.